Sign Up and Save Up To 15% OFF

Sign Up

Mystery Products – Bats, Gear & Apparel

(4 products)
View as

Unleash the excitement of surprise with our Mystery Products collection. Find hidden treasures and unique gear at Smash It Sports at unbeatable prices — bats, gloves, apparel, hats, and more, all guaranteed to be worth more than you pay.

💰 Big savings. 💣 Big surprises. 🎁 Big mystery. New mystery items rotate in as inventory changes, so check back often to see what's dropped.

What Is the Mystery Products Collection?

Every item in this collection is a surprise pick from our real, in-stock inventory — never overstock or discontinued junk. Whatever category you shop, from slowpitch bats to apparel, each mystery item carries a guaranteed minimum retail value well above the price you pay.

Shop Mystery Bats

Our original mystery lineup. Pick your tier and weight, and we'll surprise you with a certified slowpitch bat worth more than you paid.

Platinum Mystery USSSA Bats

Every bat is a certified USSSA slowpitch bat worth $299.95 or more, priced as low as $174.99.

Gold Mystery USSSA Bats

Every bat is a certified USSSA slowpitch bat worth $209.95 or more, priced as low as $139.99.

Senior Mystery Bats

Every bat is stamped Senior, worth $199.95 or more, priced as low as $119.99.

More Mystery Categories

Bats are just the start. As inventory allows, the Mystery Products collection also features surprise picks from other categories across the store, including:

Availability in each category depends on current stock, so the mix of mystery products you see today may change tomorrow — check back often for new drops.

Why Shop Mystery Products

  • Every item is verified, top-notch quality — never overstock or seconds
  • Guaranteed retail value well above what you pay
  • New categories and tiers added as inventory allows
  • Fast shipping while limited quantities last

How the Mystery Products Program Works

Choose a category (and, for bats, a tier and weight class), and we hand-select a certified, in-stock item matching your choice. For bat sizing help, check our Bat Sizing Chart before you order.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Mystery Products collection only bats?

No. While Mystery Bats are our most popular category, the collection also features surprise picks from other categories — including gloves, apparel, and headwear — as inventory allows.

Can I choose the exact item I receive?

No — that's the mystery. The specific item is randomly selected from in-stock inventory for your chosen category (and tier, for bats), but every item meets or exceeds its guaranteed minimum retail value.

What's the difference between Platinum, Gold, and Senior Mystery Bats?

Platinum and Gold Mystery Bats are both certified USSSA slowpitch bats, with Platinum guaranteeing a higher minimum retail value ($299.95+) than Gold ($209.95+). Senior Mystery Bats are stamped for Senior league play and carry either a USSSA or USA/ASA stamp, with a minimum retail value of $199.95.

Are Mystery Products eligible for return or exchange?

Because the item is randomly selected, Mystery Products are final sale and not eligible for return or exchange. See our full Return Policy for details.

Will I get a duplicate if I order more than one?

It's possible. If you place multiple orders at different times, duplicate items can occur since selection is random from current stock.

Do Mystery Products come with a warranty?

Where applicable, manufacturer warranty coverage is included — see our Warranty Info page for claim details. Coverage varies by product and category, so check the specific listing before you buy.

Explore More Gear
Back to top

Compare /5